Conservatives inhabit a subjective reality that runs on naked tribalism. Strict hierarchy isn't their goal: it's how they think everything already works. I cannot overstress: everything. If a rightful authority moved a "falling rocks" sign, the rocks would fall somewhere else.
Anything else is proof that someone is in the wrong position. Right things are things said by right people. It is impossible for someone to simply be incorrect, because there is no objective means to evaluate claims. They can only be accepted or rejected based on interpersonal trust.
So of course they figure, what they need is a really really smart guy, but one who says what they want to hear. That's all we're doing - right? That's all there is.
Their stated ideals are ad-hoc justifications. All that has ever mattered is ingroup loyalty. Nothing they do makes sense until you understand this.