This brainstorm is motivated by two recent discussions:
When is it time to switch away from youtube?
Lemmy community feedback: Should we fetch and combine comments from cross-posts on the post screen? · Issue #3415 · LemmyNet/lemmy-ui
The conversations about YouTube alternatives and PeerTube’s limitations made me test the current state of Lemmy <--> PeerTube federation.
Federation already works quite well: you can pull in PeerTube channels, subscribe, upvote, and comment from Lemmy.
But I did notice one thing. Take this Techlore video on PeerTube:
https://techlore.tv/w/9a7d20d2-4cc1-4911-8fd7-0794d8fe3bd9
-> On PeerTube: 6 upvotes, 4 comments
I pulled the video into my instance and was able to upvote it from there, so federated voting is working well: https://mander.xyz/post/37959974
I then noticed it had also been cross-posted to lemmy.world: https://lemmy.world/post/35205985
-> On lemmy.world: 37 upvotes, 9 comments
So the cross-post has significantly more engagement than the original video. This highlights a visibility issue: PeerTube creators may be getting more reach than they realize, but that engagement is fragmented across federated posts.
Brainstorm
Would it make sense to allow cross-posting of already-federated PeerTube content without breaking the link to the original object?
Upvotes/likes: These could be funneled back into the original PeerTube video, so creators get a true sense of their reach.
Comments: Less clear. Should all comments be merged into the video thread, or should they remain scoped to the Lemmy community they were posted in?
I don’t think this is “GitHub issue” ready, but it seems worth discussing.
I'm going to copy a suggestion I made on their forum here:
People who make videos on Nebula, usually also publish on YT. Publishing the same videos on PT should be fine, and some people who make linux videos are already doing that.
However, making videos takes time, money and effort, so how would the compensation work on PT? For many people, making videos is more than just a hobby.
People on Nebula may also have exclusive some videos (Nebula Originals), so I think keeping those on Nebula is the only realistic option. People who want to see those videos, can pay for Nebula, and support the channels they like that way.
Well the idea would be for Nebula to become a PT instance that HS a paywall I guess?