14
Quantum Ogres
(lemmy.world)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 03 Oct 2023
14 points (88.9% liked)
RPG
7 readers
1 users here now
Discussion of table top roleplaying games.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
My only problem with the quantum ogre is that if you're determined to have your players face a certain encounter, why even bother with the illusion of choice? Why have the left door and the right door? Why not just have a straight hallway?
Players already tend towards analysis paralysis for any choice you present, so if you're going to give them a decision, then you can at least have that decision have an impact or clear consequences. No one wants to do a bunch of prep for content the players will never touch, but part of the magic of TTRPGs is having a world that feels alive and that you can influence.
One of my favorite GMing terms I learned about recently is "showing the barrel of the gun." If you don't want to come up with two encounters - one that the players will never see and one that they will - then a much more manageable alternative is to have one option that reveals the imminent threat to the players and one that does not. And if they then bypass your planned encounter? Well, great, you showed them the threat, and they got around it.
Well i never heard that advice. But this was brought up in the video. Just because it is tge same group of zombies doesn't mean everything us the same. The players pick one path they fight them in a feild the other path they fight them along a river.
Would feel that the players picking a oath and then rolling for a rabdom encouter is not an illusion of choice?
I think it's just all a bit antithetical to how I run my games. I've really only used random encounters one time, and that was when I wanted to make a "classic dungeon crawl" and created an encounter chart to roll on when the PCs backtracked. That way, it would feel like the dungeon denizens were looking for them more the longer they were in the dungeon.
If they're picking a path to get to an objective, then I want to reflect the flavor of that choice. If they've decided to cross a swamp, then I might have them run into another boat being attacked by a strange tentacle monster. Or, if they've decided to trek through the forest, a group of fey who are sick of the mortals encroaching on their land. Preferably, this ties back into the central story: the other boat in the swamp is carrying a rival adventuring party after the same treasure as them. The fey have been enlisted by the big bad who stole the treasure in the first place.
And if they miss either of these, they'll run into them inside the dungeon eventually. These encounters are just a chance to foreshadow those things and don't feel 'wasted' to me.