371
Is this image generated by AI?
(lemmy.wtf)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 22 Jul 2024
371 points (96.3% liked)
Facepalm
186 readers
1 users here now
Anything that makes you apply your hand to your face.
founded 4 months ago
MODERATORS
This post is in itself a facepalm. Why is 'AI' the first thing everybody thinks of when they see an image they dislike / disagree with?
Yeah, it's becoming a boring trope response. I get we need to be aware of AI generated art, but not every single picture needs to be assumed as AI unless proven otherwise.
Funny that before 'AI generated images' it was 'photoshopping'. It's gotten so popular that Photoshopped images are now represented as 'AI' and vice versa.
It's mad when you think how quickly things have changed. Even a few years ago you'd find it an enormous task to persuade people that it was software that had produced a picture. Nowadays you'd have an equally hard task persuading them it wasn't.
I thought it may be AI because the lady is picking strawberries at face level. I'm only aware of strawberries that grow close to the ground.
Came to the comments to either confirm AI or learn something about strawberries. So far no luck with either but still reading.
I think it's just that the lady posing in the photo really doesn't know how strawberries work. (I would go so far as to guess that she doesn't know how a lot of things work.) She wanted to pose picking strawberries, which are a fruit, and fruits grow on trees, so she picked a random tree to pretend to pick them from. Who would even know the difference?
To me, that's the sort of thing people notice.
She knows enough about strawberries to get them from the store for the picture. She should also know they don't grow on trees. And there was probably one or more additional people there to handle the photography. Any one of them would know strawberries don't grow on trees.
AI on the other hand would easily make that assumption, especially art AI vs text AI.
You'd think that, but I've met plenty of people who are wholly ignorant about where food comes from in general. Sure it requires only one person to be ignorant if it was generated, but it is entirely plausible that both model and photographer didn't know. I don't have the chance to test it, but I would imagine that there are many pictures of people picking strawberries realistically in the training data and AI would probably only generate this if you were very specific about it being a tree.