Tankies gunna tank I guess lol ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
(^The comment I was banned for on /c/Palestine)
One thing I don't like over here on Lemmy is that when a mod action happens against you you don't get a notification of any kind. So unless you check the mod logs you'll typically never know something happened.
NGL I'm half tempted to make a bot that crawls the mod logs to tell people when something happens to their posts or comments.
It's already been requested as a feature request, see https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/4572
Presumably it'd interfere with .ml etc censoring dissenting (i.e. sane) opinions, which is why it's not happening. Same as how instance blocking was like pulling teeth
Maybe there's no good answer 'cause I'm on an app, but how do you even check the modlogs.
On the sidebar of every community in lemmy-ui is a link to the modlog. For example, here's a screenshot of this community's sidebar:
Unfortunately on Jerboa I couldn't find any way to get to the modlog. Don't know about other apps.
You can also navigate to /modlog on your instance. e.g. https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/modlog. Unfortunately it's not very easy to use, and it's not always clear. For example, when I loaded the page, one entry I saw said "mod Banned @TransFormer78@startrek.website". Which mod? Why, what did they do? Where have they been banned from?
Another entry when I look at the modlog from my instance says "mod Banned Leate_Wonceslace@lemmy.dbzer0.com from the community News@lemmy.world reason: advocating assassination expires: 4 days ago". Mostly great, I know who was banned and from where and why. I still don't know who did it, but whatever. The only catch? The ban was issued 2 hours ago. Issued 2 hours ago but expired 4 days ago? Huh?
I'm glad it exists, but I rarely look at it. It's just not practical to use most of the time.
Ah, thanks!
I'm on Sync and I don't see any convenient way of looking at it either. This info does help a lot, though.
Unfortunately I've yet to find an app that makes getting to the modlog easy so the only option I've found is to open my phone's web browser and check it that way.
At least Lemmy works better on mobile than a lot of other sites
I'm only on ShitJustWorks because I thought Lemmy.World straight-up deleted my account.
For repeatedly explaining to someone that I was arguing for copyright reform... while they just slapped the table and parroted the status quo. As if 'but! copyright! exists!' was both news and a counterargument. That sort of trolling horseshit is what moderation's supposed to be for. Not waiting for someone to say a no-no word. Or to heave a sigh and say, go ahead, make good on your adorable threat to report me, I've done nothing but humor you with more effort than your comments deserve.
But every moderator dense enough to demand "civility" never reads anything besides the comment that gets reported. And none of them have any god-damn idea what trolling looks like, so good luck getting your own reports acknowledged. On reddit I could imagine a conscious effort to ratchet discussions toward right-wing nonsense. But here? No. Here it's just ignorance of what makes discussions worth having.
If people can lie and misrepresent and spin and lie, without any fucking consequences, but 'I think this user is being dishonest' is an intolerable personal attack, you run a community for those liars.
I've literally had some of my comments (on this account and others) removed while other people agreeing with me don't have theirs removed.
Or moderators banning people for stuff that's not even against their rules but they just put it as the reason anyways.
Not to mention the amount of misinformation that flies around that goes completely unchecked.
I'm currently chilling on blahaj because the moderation is pretty good (usually) but having downvotes disabled really hampers things at times as some pretty terrible shit sometimes gets a lot of upvotes but you never see the downvotes.
Even Blahaj has the admin going to bat for outright cranks, and censoring the gentlest criticism as "gatekeeping."
Capitalized pronouns are not a gender issue. That's not how pronouns or gender work. Anyone insisting the little people call them Her Majesty deserves to be ignored at best, whether they're trans or cis.
And that's the shallow end of this conversation - I had someone insist on equal respect for emoji as pronouns. Hard no. Fuck off. I don't even respect emoji as text. I don't care how hard anyone feels it; you cannot sexually identify as a pumpkin symbol. That's not what those words mean. Me saying so is fucking obviously not the same kind of disrespect as deadnaming someone, and people trying to equate them are insulting the trans community. Trans women are women. No human being is produce.
Almost wrote "no human being is fucking produce," but I have videos to the contrary.
You won't hear me defending the admin here that's for sure. And I agree with you on everything in your comment here.
It ain't perfect here for a number of reasons but it's a pretty chill place at least in the communities I participate in on this instance. Though I have had some weird to shitty experiences with mods on this instance on more than a few occasions.
That would be s great bot
lemmy.world afaik has one or had one.
Why are ya posting about this here tho?
We don't really have a theme in this community so it's not like it doesn't fit. But we are pretty united in being against tankies, so...
Oh lemme be clear I'm not saying it should be removed or anything, I just think it's a bit of an odd space to warn others about tankie behavior or whatever. I admittedly bristle a bit when I see posts complaining about how something is moderated, and while I know they're part of forums and what-have-you, I don't think I've seen one posted in 196 like this.
So I ask outta curiosity, not condemnation.
Valid!
A warning I guess. I didn't realize some of the communities were on .ml, which is the devs "flagship" instance so they ban people for saying stuff like "tankies gunna tank".
Devs are hardcore tankies. It's unfortunate
It's best to just block the lemmy.ml instance.
Can you block instances? I never figured out how but that would be super useful.
Why not just stay away from lemmy.ml then? You can start the same communities on another instance. It would be like me going to a Nazi instance and pointing out that they ban anyone that celebrates diversity. Like, yeah... that's what they do. It's in their ethos.
I didn’t realize some of the communities were on .ml
You technically can. The issue is that when the average Joe sees five instances of the community they're looking for, and the highest users/month stat is on .ml, they'll post there for the most traction. And the problem just self-reinforces from there.
The mods are ensuring people stay away from .ml
Have you earned your ban of honor yet?
I also got banned from all the .ml stuff.
It's a badge of honor.
Here my comment that triggered their mod:
That's an incredibly stupid comment though, but congratulations I guess.
Ah, reminds me of the ol' "How quickly can you get banned from /r/sino?" challenge
Took me one comment and it was a very reasonable one that didn't bash China even. It was something about decentralizing manufacturing being good because it's not great that all the world depends on one country to make everything.
Why be a troll, though? Your comment sucks
Carp are pretty good too
So you went into a vegan community or what?
As you can see from the downvotes, this was just a random vegan feeling the need to make themselves heard. The community was "memes".
It was a very vegan oriented meme though, and the comments were filled with lots of pro vegan comments. But what this guy said was just stupid, hence the score. To get this low I think most vegans were down voting him too.
Vegans are very wierd, but anti-gmo vegans have mental health problems.
Orb?
If only it-were so simple.
i just looked at ml's modlog to see what comment got you banned and it was "Tankies gonna tank."
While I was there I saw someone talking about how they thought AI art was acceptable if someone doesn't have the spare time or money to dedicate time to getting good at art so that they can make a game people won't reject because the art is ugly, and had an entire thread worth of comments with several paragraphs each pulled and burned because they disagreed with the moderators
Extreme fragility is another thing they have in common with the far-right authoritarianism fans.
Truly one of the .ml moments of all time.
Fuck lemmy.ml
All my homies hate lemmy.ml
For basically nothing too
What/where is this view?
It's the modlog for the .ml instance.
Uhhh... Wait a minute. You got banned over the comment about Turkey potentially coming to Palestine's aid?
Not exactly, it was reply to a reply that was pointing out the unsound logic of another user saying Russia will invade Turkey if Turkey invades Israel or something like that. It was basically a satellite comment affirming that users position of how stupid that is.
Yowza, getting banned for that is ridiculous.
Yeah, it was pretty surprising but I'm still proud to be banned from an authoritarian-fascist lemmy instance.
When people on Lemmy.ml say their communities core values are different from lemmygrad.ml they look like total fucking roobs given who runs both instances (HINT: its the Lemmy core devs for both)
!meanwhileongrad@sh.itjust.works
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.