2
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] inspectorst@feddit.uk 1 points 2 weeks ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago)

Yes, in many ways it's so much dumber. If I'm taking home a salary from Company A, my livelihood is dependent on Company A, and then as part of my pay package I get given $1000 of shares in Company A, then I would cash them in as soon as l could and buy a diversified portfolio of shares in Companies B, C, D, E, etc instead.

Keeping all your eggs in one basket is a bad idea. But keeping all your eggs in a basket whose performance is directly correlated with your risk of getting made redundant seems an exceptionally bad idea!

Also, you realise that everyone who has a pension is an indirect owner of shares in hundreds of different companies? Part of the problem of Starmer using this sort of idiotic language is that it willfully plays on and exacerbates voters' lack of awareness of the world they live in and where their pension savings are going...

[-] jlou@mastodon.social 0 points 2 weeks ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago)

My personal view is the following

You're working class if

- you only own small minority percentage of voting shares of an employing corporation or non-voting preferred shares
- are an employee or you are individually or jointly self-employed as in a worker cooperative.

You're employing class if you hold large percentages of the voting shares in at least one company

There are two dual risk reduction strategies one of diversification and one of commitment

@neoliberal

[-] inspectorst@feddit.uk 1 points 2 weeks ago

How do you define 'large percentage'? Musk owns 22% of Tesla shares whereas small business owners may own 100% of their business. Do you think Musk is more working class then the latter?

Shares are just an asset just like cash. Some people choose to hold their savings in cash. Some people choose to hold them in bonds, some in shares, some in property, and so on.

When I was younger and poorer than I am today, I owned a larger value of shares than I do now because I was still saving up for a deposit on my house. Then I took out my mortgage, bought the house and the value of my ISA dropped to almost nothing as I sold most of the shares to fund my deposit. Do you think I was a capitalist when I was poorer and didn't own a house, but working class now that I have a mortgage but fewer shares?

The form in which you hold your assets is irrelevant. It's how much assets you have that counts.

this post was submitted on 28 Oct 2024
2 points (100.0% liked)

Neoliberal

271 readers
1 users here now

Woke Rainbow Capitalism (nerds)

Trains, free trade, and open borders; trans rights and taco trucks on every corner. Please read the sidebar for more information.


Community Bookmarks


Rules:

1. Instance Terms of ServiceComply with the Lemmy.world terms of service.
 
2. CivilityRefrain from name-calling, slapfights, hostility, doxxing, or any uncivil behavior that derails the quality of the conversation.   A specific one of importance you might not generally expect on Lemmy or the wider fediverse, and enforced to further community health, is Do not engage in excessive partisanship.
 
3. BigotryBigotry of any kind will be sanctioned harshly.
 
4. Unconstructive EngagementDo not post with the intent to provoke, mischaracterize, or troll other users rather than meaningfully contributing to the conversation. Don't disrupt serious discussions. Bad opinions are not automatically unconstructive.

Do not reflexively downvote just because someone has a different opinion.

Also, as a general disclaimer, keep in mind that votes on posts and comments are discoverable as they federate with other instances and that is outside the control of this community.

 
5. Off-topic CommentsComments on submissions should substantively address the topic of submission.
 
6. Glorifying ViolenceDo not advocate or encourage violence either seriously or jokingly. Do not glorify oppressive/autocratic regimes.
 
7. BrigadingRefrain from brigading other communities or fediverse instances, or coming from another community or fediverse instance and brigading this community. Links within the community are encouraged provided no other rules are broken.
 
8. Off-topic, Meta, or Duplicate PostSubmissions should be relevant to public policy or political theory. Meta posts should be posted to the discussion thread. Generally avoid editorializing submission titles.
 
9. Submission QualityLow-quality or irrelevant submissions will be removed at mod discretion. This applies in particular to low-quality or repetitive memes.
 
10. Tag Communities and/or Users WiselyDo not tag communities and/or users to troll, spam, or brigade.
 
11. Bonk-Posting/Sexual ContentGo be horny somewhere else. Do not post inappropriate content of a sexual nature. Both SFW and NSFW content can qualify. Repeat infringements can lead to bans.
 
12. Toxic Nationalism/RegionalismRefrain from condemning countries and regions or their inhabitants at-large in response to political developments, mocking people for their nationality or region, or advocating for colonialism or imperialism.


Other Fediverse Communities:


We in c/Neoliberal support:

Neoliberals can be found in many political parties and we are not dogmatic supporters of specific parties. But we tend to find ourselves agreeing more often with parties that espouse liberal values, internationalism and centrist economics, such as the Democrats in the US, Liberal Democrats in the UK, FDP in Germany, Renaissance/MoDem in France, the Liberal Party in Canada, and so on.


Further Reading:


News sources:

Here are some suggested news sources that we like and tend to find reliable. Please note that posts and threads are not at all limited to these sources!--

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS