this post was submitted on 20 Apr 2025
575 points (98.8% liked)
50501
1292 readers
322 users here now
50 States, 50 Protests, 1 Movement. https://fiftyfifty.one/ | #fiftyfiftyone
This is an unofficial community related to the 50501 movement. Find the official communities at https://50501.chat/.
founded 2 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
From a total outsiders perspective (I don't live in in the US) who has some experience in organising protests(doing so since I am 14, ran for a state rep. here,etc.): You need to find a more unified way of protesting. Yes,that can be creative,but the message has to be far more unified than it is currently.
To give you an example what I mean: I made the effort to look up foreign press coverage,some domnestic press coverage, social media and photos taken by friends of mine of one rather prominent protest location of the most recent ones.
So far I came across the following messages:
Pro Palestina
Pro Feminism
Pro Ukraine
Pro Supreme Court
Pro National parks and environmental conservation
Pro various, contending Democrats and some smaller Parties
Pro Diversity
Pro LGBTQ
Pro Choice
Against Deportations
Against Supreme Court
Against Trump personally
Against the Reps
Against science influence/budget cuts
Against influencing universities
Against Tate and Musk
Against USaid Cuts
Against US government cuts
Against tariffs
Against Milei
Against Gun Violence
Against Violence in Dafur
And surely a few more I am missing/forgot. Don't get me wrong, the USA have a lot of pressing issues. But people will judge a book by it's cover and while we all often pretend that the issue each one of us finds the most important IS the MOST IMPORTANT and anyone that doesn't think the same is an idiot, we tend to not see the wood amgonst all the trees. Because there is one drawback in this stance: Everyone has it. And once you declare "this topic is the most important" the people who support the other 40 topics as the most important topics are alienated. Which leads to infighting, some not showing up, etc. (If this reminds you of Life of Brian, well, it's a very factual movie in that regard)
But there is ONE main issue: The Trump government. While it can sometimes be useful to choose a cause that unites the people behind one even though that is not the main issue, these have to be choosen wisely. (Türkiye is one recent example: The problem is not that Imanoglu has been arrested. Nor was the problem about Gezi park back then. But it's a cause that unites the people)
This needs to be done fast and much more coordinated and "reaching all areas of society " than it is currently visible. To give you an example: European Anti-Fascist protests are often formed by a coalition of trade unions, political parties (and we are talking not about "leftist" parties but parties than are rather "mid left",e.g. Greens, social democrats, etc.), churches, sport clubs and similar social circles. Why do they bother? Because they all know if Fascism ever comes back it will get them all one after another. Just like it is now.
And yes, 50501 is a good start,but support is lacking - because of the "most important topic" issues.
This goes both ways: If on one side you need to talk about unification of people - but you do also need to shed the political groups that are not helping but actually hurting the main cause. To give you an example (and this is not taking a stance in the Palestina issue, it's just a good example that came up today during an interview): If your protest is associated with a group that uses the Hamas triangle and sees the Palestina topic as the one and only topic worth protesting for, they are hurting the main issue, their own issue (with an USA in full flight Fascism that protects Bibi doing whatever he likes Gaza will be "a summertime stroll" compared to what will follow) and alienate regular Joe and Jane as well as give the opposing side verbal ammunition to fight the whole movement. (Why I did choose this example: During the protest I looked up a foreign journalist did interview a spoksperson of some group - who was very well trained and did, despite her young age and obvious nervousness, an outstanding job- and some idiots wearing the triangle similar to the yellow jewish star worn during the Holocaust, screamed in the camera and tried to sideline the interview because anyone not willing to listen to their (very much genocidal) monologues would just tolerate children being killed.
Now, imagine Jane Average,40, who is afraid that her brother in law,who is an legal immigrant, gets deported, has more and nore problems putting food on the table due to rising costs, is afraid that her husband is loosing his job over the tarrifs and how the world will be for her daughters sees this. For years Jane Average has been voting democrats,yes. But she didn't go out of her way to do so. She is now considering going to a protest - the first one in her life.
But what are they actually protesting for? And aren't they all idiots like the one she saw on TV? And,unknown to her, her friend Juliet Somebody is also considering. If she would hear from Jane that she is going,she would go as well....etc.
TLDR: Unify your message, shed idiots, get the whole society behind one cause.