General simple idea:

We have a 2 day vote on a theme for the week (Sat-Sun), top upvoted idea comment gets selected (has to follow community rules, no NSFW themes etc.)

Once voted the challenge goes from Mon-Fri.

Throughout the week we vote all (upvote/downvote) submissions in the comments of the pinned challenge post.

The top 3 winners get featured as a pinned post for span of the next challenge, and then the process repeats. The top 3 previous winners get cycled out for the next top 3 winners next week.

Any suggestions on the process please feel free to comment!

EDIT: It seems as though this idea has positive support, if there are no objections then I will begin the process in ~12 hours at (1PM EDT 7/8/2023), any suggestions will be taken into account moving forward!