I'm in my late 20's and this is my first year since 2018 that I have not done adult recreational sports (softball and flag football) in the spring and summer. The reason for not doing them this year is because my wife and I had our first child and I did not have time to play like I usually do between work and the new child. I thought I would miss playing sports, but I really don't.
I loved sports as a kid, but playing adult sports the last few years really wore me down. I was always the captain and even the event organizer for one sport and I really liked it at first, but as the years went on I noticed it was tougher to really enjoy it. Getting people to come out each week was the biggest problem. Even people I knew personally would get super flaky and cancel hours before the game kicked off, often leaving us shorthanded. Then other teams were also a challenge. I lost my super competitive streak years ago so I really just want to have fun and get some exercise, but some people seem to be unable to accept anything short of a win and appear willing to do anything possible to improve their odds of a win including cheating or being abusive. This constant bickering of reminding opponents of the rules, only to then be accused of being rule police became very frustrating. Often I felt like my team would be very flexible to avoid conflict and it still didn't guarantee a smooth experience at all and there would still be unsportsmanlike conduct from the others. Our team wasn't always perfect either, but it was almost always the result of reacting to unfair treatment. We even had one team who mocked our female pitcher and made sexist comments. We complained to the league and the team was thrown out of the league immediately, but our pitcher was shaken heavily by the experience.
I have been heavily contemplating if I want to go back to adult rec sports, and I really struggle to justify it. I've been so much more at peace not playing and I find I enjoy more going to professional sports and just watching casually rather than playing myself. Adult sports just feel so different compared to playing when I was a kid where it was about having fun and making friends. Now it just feels like people are only interested in winning and dominating their opponent even if it's a meaningless game. Why do people do this? Should I just quit forever or should I give it another chance?
Time to find a different group or a less organized one. I play basketball once a week with a group of friends/friends of friends. It’s non-competitive; we shoot for teams to mix it up every game. When we get 8 (4 on 4) or more we play full court.
It’s fun, it keeps us all in (a little bit of) shape, and the lack of formal organization makes it easier not to burn out.
I like the idea of this. A open and non competitive atmosphere where you can play with your friends and family. I think the organized league style is killing my love of playing sports. Our league is supposed to be "fun first" but I find that is rarely the case. I think I do need a change and what you described here is very appealing
The guys in my office started it about 15 years(!) ago - playing in the winter to stay in shape for golf in the summer. They were in their early 20s and I was pushing 40 at the time. People have come and left over the years. We picked up a pair of international PhD students two winters ago, then they graduated. We have about 12-14 on a group text and we do a roll call the night before to make sure we have enough to play. We use an open gym at the local rec center most of the year, and then commandeer outdoor courts wherever we find them when the rec center has kid camps in the summer. We've talked about joining a league, but we're all busy professionals, many with families and young kids, so time is tight. There's a lot of good-natured trash talk and we're all pretty gassed by the end of the hour. I hate it when I miss because I get a better cardio workout than anything I would do myself.