Curated Tumblr

I don't completely agree. While an accident is one example where intent is missing, publishing accidental shots could be a form of art in its own way as the act of publishing itself has intent associated with it.

Yeah, find interesting accidental photos that tell a story would be a creative work of art. The photos wouldn't be before, but putting them together could be.

Furthermore, nature photography is in my view also art, but provides much less control than studio photography, as the scene and subject are free to do whatever they want.

Like I said, composition and subject are important. That doesn't mean you stage them. It means make something interesting out of the scene.

I don't think recording everything would make it less of an artpiece: you would have intentionally chosen to record continuously to capture that frame, and skimmed though those frames to find the right one.

Yeah, the act of choosing a frame could be artistic. That's not what I meant. I meant an amazing image could exist within the frames. It isn't art just because it's there. Sure, something could be done with it to make it art. Like you imply, intention is the important part. You're agreeing, but you're adding intention to all the examples I'm giving. Without the intention I assume you agree that they aren't art.

There are limits to what repeatedly prompting an AI model can do, but that doesn't stop you from doing other things with the output...

Sure, you can do things with the output. I've proposed the idea of making a piece about the soulessness of AI generated images, and making a collage of AI generated images next to artist created ones, to show how it's missing the creative spark a human can add. This would be taking AI generated images and making art out of them. They wouldn't be art right out of the model though.