32
The case for Nushell
(www.sophiajt.com)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 03 Apr 2024
32 points (100.0% liked)
Shell Scripting
3 readers
1 users here now
From Ash, Bash and Csh to Xonsh, Ysh and Zsh; all shell languages are welcome here!
Rules:
- Follow Lemmy rules!
- Posts must relate to shell scripting. (See bottom of sidebar for more information.)
- Only make helpful replies to questions. This is not the place for low effort joke answers.
- No discussion about piracy or hacking.
- If you find a solution to your problem by other means, please take your time to write down the steps you used to solve your problem in the original post. You can potentially help others having the same problem!
- These rules will change as the community grows.
Keep posts about shell scripting! Here are some guidelines to help:
- Allowed: Release Announcement of a command-line program designed for scripted use (e.g. bash, bats, awk, jq, coreutils/moreutils)
- Allowed: Tutorials on using shell languages or supplementary tools designed for scripted use
- Allowed: Code review/help requests for shell languages or supplementary tools designed for scripted use
- NOT Allowed: Announcement of a CLI or TUI program that is not designed for scripted use (Yes, your fancy Zsh plugin which pretty-prints the date and time using only builtins is very cool, but unless you actually want to discuss the code itself, please check out !commandline instead!)
- NOT Allowed: Domain-specific tutorials that do not involve shell scripting as a core component (e.g. docker-compose, ansible, nix). If you really love one of these, I'm sure there's a community out there ready to talk about them!
- NOT Allowed: Code review requests for non-shell programming languages and configuration languages (e.g. Python, Yaml)
In general, if your submission text is primarily shell code, then it is welcome here!
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
As much as I want to champion nushell, the problem is that it isn't available on every machine like traditional shells.
That means my whole organisation need to have nushell installed on every machine, and even then, any scripts using nushell is effectively useless outside the organisation.
How many scripts get re-used outside of the org, though?
There are tons av resources (scripts, guides, examples) that make up the backbone of a lot of IT departments.
If you're setting a new organisation, you can chose to go with nushell, but then you have to accept that you either need to write all scripts from scratch, or you need to convert an existing script to nushell. If you put nushell into an existing department/organisation, then you face the same problem.
Before there are substantial resources to solve common sysadmin tasks in nushell, organisational adoption is unlikely due to the cost.