Pike is too much of a boy scout. Sisko has that little bit of crazy that keeps you on edge. Is he going to kiss you, or commit a war crime? It's exciting!

A little temporal shifting and Pike is a deer in headlights. Sisko was a god before breakfast and still raised a kid single. We don't even wanna see the Pike from Mirror world. *shudders

Who is Janeway then? What about any of the other captains?

I recently discovered hell on wheels, while waiting out the next season of snw. I swear I need a fan to be able to watch it! Holy drool!