19
submitted 2 weeks ago by troyunrau@lemmy.ca to c/ottawa@lemmy.ca
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] troyunrau@lemmy.ca 17 points 2 weeks ago

Posting this one despite not being a resident of Ottawa. Because I'm somewhat of an ice guru, having been involved in the construction of many ice roads, runways, etc.

There is a rule of thumb in ice safety engineering called "Gold's Equation". Expressed in metric, it goes: w=4h² where h is the thickness in cm, and w is the weight it can sustain in kg.

The equation has been used safely for decades, but there are several variations on it.

(1) It assumes that your measurements are made manually, and that there is some statistical variation that are not captured by the exact locations of your measurements. If you have something that can do continuous measurements (like a GPR), you can use 7 as your factor instead of 4, as you've got better info about the thinnest spots.

(2) It assumes the ice is clear ice (also called blue ice). White ice is treated as only contributing half to thickness because it is weaker.

(3) It assumes the load isn't static. If a load is parked on the ice for 12 or more hours, you treat that load as weighing twice as much.

With all of this in mind, what usually happens is: you go measure the ice. If it passes w=4h² at the outset for your required load, you kind of just accept and move on. But if it doesn't pass, you start looking for ways to get your load approved -- hire a GPR and scan, or spray water on the surface to build more white ice faster, etc.

30cm, as per the article, will handle loads of up to 3600kg. Which is a lot, particularly when compared to skaters. But a Zamboni full of water or a snowplow or something could be risky. Bring out a GPR and truly find your thinnest spots and maybe you can get 4200kg approved. Etc.

This is likely a non-story, for those of use versed in ice safety. But it was worth my time to type it out :)

[-] BedSharkPal@lemmy.ca 2 points 2 weeks ago

Appreciate the great comment! TIL ice gurus exist.

this post was submitted on 02 Nov 2024
19 points (100.0% liked)

Ottawa

997 readers
1 users here now

News, events, discussions, and what not from Ottawa, Ontario.

Municipal website: https://ottawa.ca/


Rules

  1. Be polite and respectful.
  2. Please only post content relevant to the City of Ottawa or to its residents.

Ottawa on the Fediverse:

empty

Ottawa chatrooms:

Please note the following:

* All chatrooms are linked together. If you join one room your messages will be copied to the other platforms.

* Matrix is an open source and potentially distributed chat protocol. The matrix room listed is hosted on matrix.org, a somewhat centralized hub for a lot of currently public rooms. Though the protocol itself is free, libre and open source, the deployment of the protocol resembles a centralized service. This may be fixed in the future with the deployment of independent servers.

* Be aware that both Telegram and Discord are centralized proprietary platforms and do not necessarily protect your rights nor privacy while simultaneously giving power to corporations.

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS