14
Unusual turn structures
(feddit.de)
I'm tinkering with a framework to implement board games in c# (similar to boardgame.io in JS) part of that is getting a handle on turn structures. (What is a round? what is a turn? who gets to go when? etc)
So I've gone through all my games and looked for recurring patterns and exceptions to them and here's what I've collected so far:
- There's always at least one structure that handles how player act or "take turns"
- the vast majority of games do traditional turns - one player does things, then then another,
- usually in a fixed order maybe going forward some times and backward other times.
- sometimes the order can change
- also possible are:
- turn order decks (you don't know who goes next but know that everyone gets a turn)
- action tracks (where whoever is furthest back gets to go next, possibly resulting in an uneven number of turns)
- the next player is dependent on an action of the previous player
- it's also possible that players can play simultaneously
- a complete free for all is pretty common
- it's also possible that players can act freely to some point, then have to wait for everyone else to catch up
- another consideration, both for concurrent and sequential play is that sometimes some players are excluded (Codenames for example lets all guessers on a given team act concurrently but not the leaders or the other team)
- there can be different rules at different times (like first picking a tile in sequence then everyone can place it simultaneously)
- and there can be nested rules (like every player gets to run an auction but in every auction each player get's to bid as well)
- one relatively common special case is where certain actions on a player's turn result in decisions being needed from other players (trades, attacks, "each player ..." effects)
- the vast majority of games do traditional turns - one player does things, then then another,
- there are often structures that simply subdivide another structure
- they can occur at any level. A game may be divided into "setup" and "play", a round could be divided into different phases but a single player's turn might also be divided into smaller steps.
- these subdivision usually restrict / specify which actions are allowed in them
- these subdivision often come with limits like: you can only do N actions
- sometimes a player can "pass" sometimes they cannot
I'm wondering if anyone can think of an instance that is not covered by these "rules".
Looks quite comprehensive! Some cases that may or may not fit in already:
Thanks a lot for those examples! Totally forgot about those "extra turn" effects. That'll be fun.
I had already considered a bunch of concepts about how a phase can end but not that it might be completely independent from any player action.
The Gloomhaven scenario probably is the easiest of these since it is merely a variant of the general "player actions result in change of player order" case