There is clearly a problem that most of the politics and news communities on Lemmy are unpleasant places to take part in discussion. People yell at each other. The tone of disagreements is that of saying what your opinion is, and insulting the other person if they don't agree with your opinion, or a bunch of people giving quick one-off statements like "well I think it's this way" or "no you're wrong" which adds nothing. I've heard more than one person say that they simply don't participate in politics or news communities because of it.
Well, behold:
I have made some technology which attempts to take a much heavier handed approach to moderation, by just detecting assholes or people who aren't really contributing to the conversation, in other communities, and just banning them pre emptively en masse. In its current form, it bans about half of hexbear and lemmygrad, and almost all of the users on lemmy.world who post a nonstop stream of obnoxiously partisan content. You know the ones.
In practice it's basically a whitelist for posting that's easy to get on: Just don't be a dick.
I'd like to try the experiment of having a ~~political~~ community with this software running the banlist, and see how it works in practice, and maybe expand it to a news community that runs the same way. There's nothing partisan about the filtering. You can have whatever opinion you want. You just can't be unproductive or an asshole about the way you say your opinion. And the bans aren't permanent, they are transient based on the user's recent past behavior.
(Edit: I think making a general news community might fit better with slrpnk than politics. In thinking about it and talking with people, I think electoral politics just doesn't belong in the slrpnk feed, but maybe general news specifically with the political bickering that comes along with it being muted, would be a positive for the instance at the same time as I get to test out my little software project.)
I don't want to explain in too much detail how the tech works, because I think some segment of assholes will want to evade the tech to come into the community and be assholes again. But I'd also want to set up a meta community where anyone who did get banned can ask questions or make complaints about it. (As long as that offering doesn't turn into too much of a shit show that is.)
Is slrpnk a place where a little experiment like this could find a good home? What does everyone think of the idea?
Yes.
In my opinion, for what you're trying to achieve, this would literally help a lot of people.
I was even going to mention if you thought of providing examples to the community of what NOT TO DO so ppl can avoid the ban hammer.
I think examples and such would help get you to where you want the community to be faster, and also it shows you're being transparent with everyone and that's what most ppl appreciate and respect.
If you don't provide a guide like that they might feel like a wool is being pulled over their eyes.
I mean you're not required to care about that, yes that's true, I'm only saying I think it would paint you and your goal here in a better/ Your trying to help everyone light rather then assuming you're trying to silence everyone if that makes sense.
That sounds like a good idea. I can make a wiki or sticky post with some examples of what type of thing can get you banned.
If you're interested, you should try this community idea I had. You can use it, I don't care. But it would be an interesting experiment for this I think maybe give you some insight ? It'd be a fun way to see how users can adhere to strict rules in political communities.
Community - Extremely Polite Politics: Where everyone can argue and be rude to eachother about politics BUT it MUST ONLY BE WRITTEN IN EXTREMELY FORMAL AND POLITE LANGUAGE think 1800s kind of but to the point of Ridiculousness. Example: Leftist might I inquire about your beliefs in X Y and Z and why it appears as though, you are most certainty incorrect on all of the above issues as mentioned? No cussing no slang. None of that.
https://hilariouschaos.com/post/266168
Just a thought
I like the general thinking of these. I was aiming with this bot to achieve very similar things. Meaning, certain types of discussions are impossible on the internet right now because there's no penalty for being a jerk or hard to talk to, as long as you're within the bounds of the community rules. The types of discussions that I want to make possible are very similar to the conversations you're talking about in these communities.
I think you should try it. You can create the community idea I mentioned on our instance if you want, (Extremely Polite Politics. You can call it something else I don't care) Not to test the bot you made though as I am not the server admin. Creating the above community would be basically a way for you to experiment and get a feel for what you're ultimately trying to accomplish without the heavy commitment.
Think of it like it's a game. Everyone's allowed to say what they usually would say I guess (No violations of TOS though)
But they literally HAVE TO keep it Extremely formal and polite otherwise ban from community. It doesn't have to be a permanent ban from this community, but it needs to be long enough to where when they come back, they'll know they have to be more careful.
I think a 5 day to a week ban at most, would be the ideal option. Possibly leave yourself a note to notify you either on the modlog or something else that will give you a notification to unban them and notify them their ban time is up. But that's a curiosity on your part if you want to do that u don't have too.
However that open line of communication builds trust in your moderation and that you're actually following your own rules. Bans won't be because they're leftist or conservative bans will be because their wording is rude, baligerant, angry and so forth.
So they're able to speak their minds but just not in the way they want to.
Also it will be a fun way less stressful to and more entertaining and humorous as a reader or lurker. You'll get to see throughou and consistent back and forth without the toxicity that just makes you feel nasty and gets your angry.
I say do it ! But I know and understand if not interested. I'm only meaning to be encouraging that's all
I'm fairly committed to this bot as my way of achieving the goal, as opposed to a mod enforced rule of overt politeness. Yours sounds fine as an alternative thing to try but I would rather stick with my idea for now, I appreciate the offer though.
Yea that's cool dude no hard feelings 😎 I understand
Yea I think that would really show effort on your part of 'trying to make it work' and not 'working against' if that makes sense.
Hell dude, you use chatgpt? Use the voice option and have it type it up for you to save some time. Obviously edit for specifics and clarity. Even ask it's opinion on it for shits and giggles lol
I do that it's interesting sometimes. But good luck ok ! U got this !
Thanks. Let's see what happens.
I don't anticipate it being a "working against" thing for an overwhelming majority of people. Most people's experience should be simply that they get to talk about politics without a bunch of disruptive comments all over the place.
You're right that anything I can do to show transparency will help create that, because it would be easy to interpret the place as a "working against" thing where everyone has to be obedient to my way or else I'll ban them, even if everything with the bot works perfectly and there's no reality to that at all. More likely, everything won't work perfectly, and there will be some small number of people who legitimately wind up tangling with the bot even if they are fine.
I do anticipate there will be a certain population that will get very upset that they're not allowed to come in and make whatever type of hostile or disruptive comments they want, and make a big stink about how it's grossly unfair that I am running the community like my own little echo chamber and kicking out any unpopular opinion, even though 99% of the time nothing like that is happening. I plan to ignore those people.
Yea you'll be fine man don't sweat it. I hope it works out where everyone including yourself is happy with the result.
Don't ever spend a second 'worrying' about lemmy hissy fit throwers. You couldn't pay me to spend my time trying to please all of them because then that would mean I'm in fucking hell 🤣
You can never please an army of entitled, self important, politically obsessed, and passive aggressive internet people no matter what you do. Someone is not gunna be happy for whatever reason, but you're not responsible for their feelings.
Down votes don't mean shit 🤣 other then you're right and they're fucking mad about it and need to be able to press a button because you're not kissing their ass and catering to them. Children throw fits that's what that is.
Anyway I'm done preaching lol touch base with me if or when you get this going. I'm not gunna participate but I would like to see how it unfolds