Ask Lemmy

Nice try, raider. I'm staying in the vault.

I think there are too many factors to account for to give a good answer.

But realistically: If the walled city was stable (relative to what I knowz I can only compare things to what I know and have experienced) and my life was alright or better then or course I would stay. If I had kids in that city I would probably stay.

If it was a shitty life inside those walls, of course I would find a way to stealthily leave.

I'd tell myself I'm going to do it, but chicken out.

Depends on if the colossal Titan and armored Titan breaks through the wall. And I become radicalized at the sight of my mother being eaten that forces me to bring about the downfall of all humanity.

It depends on the danger I was told about. If it was poisoned gas like Bad Boy Bubby then I don't think so. If it was just there are dangerous or violent people out there then maybe.

If there were rumours that the outside world wasn't actually dangerous that might have swayed me when I was younger but probably not now.

Y’all should watch Silo.

Is that you, Eren?

It’s called New Jersey since those people can’t pump their own gas, they can’t venture into the rest of America haha.

OP go watch the movie The Village

I'd suspect there's something I'm not being told but I wouldn't be brave enough to find out

Absolutely. I was teaching English with Mormons in Kiev, UA in 2014 (as a volunteer, I am not Mormon). The nonprofit we were with stressed to us that we should absolutely, under no circumstance, go to Maidan (city center). This was when the revolution was just starting. Of course I went anyway.

At least when I was in Ukraine at that time, all the discord was contained within Maidan and the eastern regions. Life elsewhere went on as usual. I'm not sure if it is the same now. But it felt like going between two worlds.

Personally? Probably not. Im not much of a rebel or confident enough to push a boundary like that

But we kinda have something like that irl.

If i remember right

The Amish think technology is evil but some leave and embrace the modern world despite that

Shit. There are no walls keeping me in, and no one is telling me the world outside is dangerous, but I barely ever leave anyway. When I do leave, it's only to a small handful of relatively close places where I feel comfortable.

Got "Freedom Cities" on the mind, eh?

depends on how difficult it is to leave?

If you look at space.

We are on a walled sphere, and my entire life I've been told I can't survive in space.

Would I visit space? Sure.. but I can't get there.

I'm not moving out of my Fallout Vault, unless Overseer approves or Water Chip fails.

I am disabled and unable to drive thus holding a proper job is difficult.

i've been on an effective island with 'visits' to 'the outside' on rare occasions and largely when picking up things from lowes or family functions.

What you ask is not a hypothetical for me.

For sure. I'd volunteer to be the first person on Venus knowing it would be a death sentence.

Depends on how small or hard/easy life is there. I would argue that there is a sweet spot where if life is just hard enough to keep you busy but comfortable enough to keep you satisfied, most would never care. Too hard and there will be those who would take the risk, too comfortable and there would be those who would seek it out.

Personally if I lived my exact same life but in that city, I would go out at least once.

Is anyone actively trying to stop me from leaving? Is there any punishment for doing so?

Is the "dangerous" outside because of something invisible, like a plague? Or is the "dangerous" a nebulous claim of "nobody goes out there"

I think plenty of people would try it just to say they did, just like the real world.

I’d probably go insane from living around that many humans. Normal cities are awful for me, I can’t imagine being in one I can never leave.

Depends if there were dumb lumbering giants outside that would eat me, 'Attack on Titan' style.

~This~ ~comment~ ~is~ ~licensed~ ~under~ ~CC~ ~BY-NC-SA~ ~4.0~

This is the plot of The Village by M Night Shyamalan. Good movie.

All it takes is for leadership to slip up one time to start questioning everything else they told you. Like learning the tooth fairy doesn't exist, casting doubt on the easter bunny and Santa Claus - except there's incentives for belief. Would I go on with the charade while harbouring doubts? Escape entirely? Depends.

At the very least I'd carve a glory hole in the wall.

It depends on a number of factors.

How thorough is the isolation/how “high” are the walls? Can I perceive the world outside the walls in any way?

How good is the propaganda?

Do I have anything to lose other than my life? Do I have a community I care about within the city? A family? Children?

Depends on how the city is run. If it's anything like Paranoia's Alpha Complex, I'd probably die before even getting the chance to think about doing anything treasonous like that

City? Probably yes. Country? Probably no.

It really depends on the Size of the "cage" and what it has to "offer" to me. (how entertained I am, how well-off I am)

Assuming I'm the same person I am today, then I would probably want to know more. "Dangerous" isn't a cause it's an effect; I want to know why it's dangerous. Then I want to know what can be done to change that.

That you, Morgoth? Stop trying to trick me into revealing the location of Gondolin.

It depends on how sus the people telling me that seemed. I would definitely question, but the desire to see what is on the outside would probably be inversely proportional to how content I was with life on the inside.

If I was like, "This place fucking sucks," and they said, "TS, there's nowhere else to go," I might take my chances.

Nah, I'd probably believe it, unless things inside the city were so bad I had some reason to doubt.

I have always questioned authority, so I would probably sneak out but not go very far.

I thought you might have been thinking about Transformers One.

If everything I need is in the city, I wouldn't leave. I would only leave if pushed to.