On my multi-player play through Wyll fell hard for my Paladin (probably because he's a goody two-shoes) and when he asked him to dance I was like "sure let's have a fun time in face of this overwhelming catastrophe" and then after the dance was done I quickly realized it was quite a bit more than a dance. When I politely informed Wyll that I did not care for him in that way the look of hurt and betrayal he gave me... it made me wonder if I should quick reload and be gay for him, so I didn't hurt his feelings. -_- poor Wyll.

Withers is the real catch.

Karlach forced my first character to do a heel-face turn when I met her

he gets all of us the first time. that handsome elf.

This is me but replace will with Karlach and Astarion with Shadowheart.

Replace Karlach for Wyll, and replace literally every other party member for Astarion.