They could continue funding Marginalia Search and other NLnet projects such as Stract.
Those are real independent indexes.
this post was submitted on 16 Aug 2025
373 points (98.7% liked)
Privacy
40932 readers
951 users here now
A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.
Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.
In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.
Some Rules
- Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn't great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
- Don't promote proprietary software
- Try to keep things on topic
- If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
- Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
- Be nice :)
Related communities
much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Broseph, this link rounds up to a year old.
November 2024. Remember how innocent we all were back then?
wE'Re not GoiNg bAcK!!!!!!
WE WILL WIN! WE WON'T REST!
lol, now it's "we won't resist..."
I've been using SearX for over a year now. https://priv.au/
It returns old-school, unranked results. It currently has at least 50 Instances you can choose from. https://searx.space/
What do you mean by unranked? Because it doesn't maintain its own database, just proxies other search engines and aggregates them
Furthermore, priv.au seems to include only Google in its default search engines so its really just Google through a proxy. Good for privacy but doesn't really help you get away from big tech
4get is wayyyyy better imo, here's a list of many instances. https://4get.ca/instances
Edit: because I think it's funny as well, here is the creator of 4get self made comparison between 4get and searx
I don’t know from where he got the 2Gb RAM usage because my searxng instance uses 45MiB of RAM.
Woah, this is cool.
To me, it looks like it basically anonymizes your search through a search engine of your choice.
Meaning, you can still use google for a search if you choose, but the data they would usually collect is out of reach.
Am I understanding this correctly?
You are correct, it is just a privacy respecting meta search engine! I self host my own instance, another thing to love.
It's the only real way to go.
Cool cool cool.
My go to test is to search for water shoes / swimming shoes that are either size EU 48 or extra wide.
This shiet can't even find only "water shoes", instead recommending shoes to me.
Seems to be useless trash-proxy to Bing and Google?
Very cool, but this is old news from 2024. I wonder how they're doing now.
I think it has already launched, but still only serving a small portion of traffic
Edit: it has https://staan.ai/
As soon as I saw the post, I thought, "you mean AI?". Yup.
Gross
Cool! Perhaps I'll give Qwant another shot. Thanks for sharing :)
Please at least make it available to use with SearXNG
I used qwant in the past somewhat, briefly, but this made me switch entirely and will make an effort this time to stick with it.
genuine question; would a council moderated federated search index work? i say moderated just to keep out right wing, bigoted sites, and csam. but like a search index not owned by one company
edit: stupid typos T_T
Seeing how some Lemmy instances are a little too ban-happy, I don't think I'd want centralized moderation. The current closest thing would be Yacy. I've been playing around with Yacy, but the ranking sucks and is slow (I believe the Page Rank algorithm is turned off by default because it would make it even slower).
i say moderated just to keep our right wing, bigoted sites, and csam
That is one hell of a typo
grr oops i meant out ugh T_T
How is it in terms of privacy and results now? I tried it a month or two back and it was not good. I really want to get behind tree planting but these issues are a block
Well, until now it's an alpha, only with a little more as the crappy Bing API, but I think that it will raise fast when are the collaboration with all other EU search engine begin to work as planned. At the moment I'll continue with Andi (IMHO the best AI search ever), Startpage and Mojeek, which offers the best results and privacy.
It's late in the day. Perplexity Set itself up as a search engine with AI. Don't know whose index they use.
I rarely use a search engine anymore directly. I used to use Startpage which is/was a proxy for Google. And everybody knows how useful Google's results are these days.
So I use Perplexity for search.
Since we're on c/privacy; from perplexity itself:
What Does Perplexity Do With User Information?
Perplexity:
Collects: Search history, queries, device and location data, browsing activity, and navigational behavior (especially via its new AI-powered browser).
Uses: These data points help personalize results, train their models, improve functionality, and—crucially—build detailed user profiles for targeted ads and marketing.
Potential Risks: Privacy experts warn this data collection may turn users into marketing profiles, similar to surveillance practices seen in other big tech companies. Even actions outside the Perplexity app (via their browser) may be tracked and leveraged.
Transparency and Privacy: Perplexity does not offer strong privacy protections (like end-to-end encryption), and isn't fully transparent about how all user information is used. Cookies, device fingerprinting, and web beacons may track even non-logged-in users.
Enterprise risks: Businesses using Perplexity’s enterprise tools must be cautious about uploading sensitive data, as it could be used for model training and not always protected from leaks.
Very fair point. I'm embarrassed. Sorry.
No need to apologize, but it's good to be aware of the policies of various applications you use and promote.
I use perplexity occasionally myself, aware of the above, so I only do more general searches with it.
I have a self-hosted Perplexica instance I use for anything more sensitive.
Andisearch privacy policy:
Protecting Privacy We promise not to share your data with anyone else.
We only collect and retain sufficient data to help our customers use the service effectively, when they want to create an account or be remembered between devices and sessions, and to improve the service we provide.
No data is shared with any other person or company, and personal information is not available to our team members beyond that directly required for customer support and service.
What we do to try to protect you There is a limit to what we can do while still providing links to external websites and displaying content. But while you're searching, we do our best to try to shield our users from the worst intrusive aspects of the Web.
We don't store any cookies.
We block Google's FLoC (Federated Learning of Cohorts) tracking technology from this app.
We don't log or store your IP address. It's used to lookup your approximate location (nearest town) for location searches only, then discarded. It is never passed to third-parties.
We only use your GPS or detailed location for searches with your express permission, and then only to approximate the area. Your GPS location details are not stored or passed to any third-parties.
Searches are anonymous and private to you. We don't log searches.
We only use analytics within our service to improve it for our users.
We block referrers on external links and use "nofollow noopener noreferrer" to protect you.
We do not share any customer data with any third parties.
We collect only the data needed to provide the service.
We don't use any off-site or third-party user tracking. There is no ad tracking such as Facebook's or analytics platforms like Google Analytics.
No advertising display or advertising tracking.
We use randomized proxies to retrieve content for preview and reader mode.
We use https encryption everywhere including for external links wherever available.
We proxy images and try to strip third-party cookies from any reader content as much as possible.
We display embedded videos and content for our customer's convenience (so you can play a YouTube video in chat), but they are in a sandbox to help protect you, and restricted to only major reputable web services (like YouTube or Spotify). An embedded video might have cookies outside of our control.
Well that sounds terrible
Every time I'm reminded about Ecosia I go to their AI and burn some electricity.